January 30, 2014

State of Hawaii vs. County of Kauaʻi

Following close on the heels of the legal suit over Kauaiʻs Ordinance 960 (formerly Bill 2491), two bills have been introduced at the state level - House Bill 2506 and Senate Bill 3058 - that would have that “No law, ordinance, or resolution of any unit of local government shall be enacted that abridges the right of farmers and ranchers to employ agricultural technology, modern livestock production, and ranching practices ..."
Update: This very same language is in another piece of legislation as Senate Bill 110 and not adopted in committee (4 Feb 2014).
They might as well just have stated clearly: we don't trust counties to have the sense to have a say about how farms and ranches operate on their own islands.

Local law is already very much subject to override by state which is in turn subordinate to federal law (as I wrote about previously including the less well known legal principle called Dillonʻs rule which further limits the purvey local government to only those subjects they are explicitly empowered to legislate). That some state legislators feel compelled to specifically forbid local ordinances in the realm of agriculture can only be interpreted as a simple lack of trust.

According to a recent editorial in The Garden Island - and it may be a first for the latest Oahu-controlled incarnation of that periodical that I agree with this one - two local Kauai representatives in the state legislature are the ones introducing this legislation: Rep. Dee Morikawa (D-Koloa-Niihau) and Rep. James Tokioka (D-Koloa-Wailua). They seem to see their vital role at the state level as being about blocking our county council from bothering to get involved with things agricultural on the island.

The hubris of disempowering local government in perpetuity is astounding in itself, much less on the heels of the dramatic events on Kauai over the past several months that if anything clearly demonstrate how vital these issues are for so many folks here. Since the state level status quo - understaffed, minimal regulation and a voluntary program concocted in the eleventh hour ahead of Kauai 960 (2491) - is quite favorable to the big corporations, one has to assume that in writing off the anti-GMO crowd these representatives owe a heavy allegiance to the other side.

However, I donʻt want to underestimate the subtlety of the issues nor the intricacies of the power plays. Over at Kauai Eclectic, Joan raises some good questions about how fit Kauai is to self-govern. I would agree that the debate here - 2491 being just one prominent example - was less than statesman-like and that rational, well reasoned opinion was in very short supply.

So I would say that yes, Kauai has a lot of room for improvement, but then I would also say that at the state and federal levels - even at the UN - government could do a much better job as well. Be that as it may, local government certainly has a vital role to play here and I would need a lot better argument than “It’s a right to farm bill,” before we irrevocably disempower the counties. In the end inclusive government that respects locale must be the best system: suppressing local control always amounts to suppression of the weaker county by the more powerful state, and that just isnʻt democratic, or even moral.

I have seen it reported that these bills are not expected to get very far and the threat of passing appears small now, but that Kauai's own representatives are doing these maneuvers in the first place is unsettling, and of course, predicting the future of legislation is hardly reliable.

November 16, 2013

Bill 2491 becomes law

Bill No. 2491, Draft 2 - A BILL FOR AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND THE KAUA’I COUNTY CODE 1987, AS AMENDED, BY ADDING A NEW ARTICLE 22 TO CHAPTER 22, RELATING TO PESTICIDES AND GENETICALLY MODIFIED ORGANISMS (Laid on Table 11/07/2013)
The Kauaʻi County Council today voted to override the mayor's veto of Bill 2491 - 5 to 2 - in another dramatic turn of events in the GMO struggle unfolding on the island.

Five votes were needed to override the veto, and up until yesterday the council stood at six members, but just yesterday Mason Chock was appointed to fill the vacancy and it turns out that he cast the deciding vote. After voting for the bill last month, Nadine Nakamura resigned from the council to become the mayor's managing director, removing one likely override vote from contention.

After having signaled that they would vote on the override one member short, the council on Thursday they voted to table the veto override vote; on Friday they appointed Mason Chock to the council; then on Saturday they overrode the veto.

Meanwhile, spurred by all the 2491 hubbub, earlier this week at the state level there was an announcement of a new "good neighbor" program (PDF) consisting of entirely voluntary notification, reporting, and the establishment of buffer zones.

The county has nine months to prepare to implement the new law and there are sure to be many twists and turns between now and then.

Links:



November 1, 2013

Kauaʻi Bill 2491 vetoed

After taking the maximum time allowed the mayor vetoed Kauaʻi Bill 2491 (PDF link) yesterday in a move that surprised many, releasing a 76 page report detailing the decision (PDF link) containing the mayorʻs statement for release, the transmittal from the council to the mayor upon passage of the bill, and the until now secret legal opinion on the bill from the county attorneyʻs office.

“I have always said I agree with the intent of this bill to provide for pesticide use disclosure, create meaningful buffer zones and conduct a study on the health and environmental issues relating to pesticide use on Kaua‘i,” stated the Mayor. “However, I believe strongly that this bill is legally flawed. That being the case, I had no choice but to veto.”
I am hardly qualified to assess the legal opinion but regardless of those details what I would very much like to understand is how the process broke down here. Specifically, since the bill was introduced four months ago (June 26) and from the beginning was clearly a major public issue for the county, why didn't the county attorney, the mayor, and the council work together to draft something that met the technical legal requirements of the intended goals which the mayor says he supports?

The council worked with attorneys as well as the mayor throughout the process so the possibilities seem to be:

  1. The council was never advised how they might fix the supposed legal flaws.
  2. The council was advised but refused to accept suggested changes for legal purposes.
  3. It is impossible to achieve the goals of Bill 2491 at the county level.
The county attorney opinion consists of four sections - an Introduction, Legal Issues, Specific Challenges, and a short Conclusion. Why is there no Suggested Amendments section? Just as one example, there is an issue related to the bill assigning enforcement responsibility to the Office of Economic Development: surely the opinion could have recommended to the council a more suitable department to handle implementation.



The legal opinion released is stamped as confidential: what are the consequences of publicizing the opinion?


  1. Does this effectively subvert the council overriding the veto because now the county is in a much compromised position should it enact the bill, having disclosed all the potential flaws and anticipated legal attacks it fears?
  2. Did the mayor unilaterally leak the confidential document to support his veto, or consult with if not get approval of the county attorney and/or county council (who had already decided against disclosure)?
The mayor concludes: “I would like to state that, despite this veto, I absolutely believe that the spirit of 2491 will be implemented on Kauai in accordance with applicable federal, state and county laws and regulations,” he wrote to the council. “It would be my preference to achieve the goal through cooperation and understanding, instead of through adversarial legal action.” Isn't a veto adversarial?

See Kauaʻi Eclectic blog coverage of the veto and the response for more details.

Given the mayor's statement of agreement with intent I have to conclude that either county government is either incompetent to write legislation, so encumbered by state and federal law as to be completely disempowered, or both. Kauaʻi seems to have a record for bungling popularly supported initiatives and getting into legal hot water, possibly causing more damage than good. Another example would be management of vacation rentals (Transient Vacation Rental) as documented in the Abuse Chronicles also at Kauaʻi Eclectic which I believe has been through three iterations becoming increasingly dysfunctional.

I believe we have some good people on the council so is the problem that the system itself is broken, too many layers, too risk averse, with too much complexity?