May 12, 2014

Election year

This is an election year and in the past few weeks signs have been popping up along the road or in front of homes and businesses in support of candidates. Less than two months remain to register to vote.

  • Primary election is August 9, 2014
  • General election is November 4, 2014

County mayor, council, and prosecuting attorney will be on the ballot in addition to governor and state representative. The county council members are "at-large" meaning each serves the entire island rather than having regional seats. The top 14 vote getters in the primary vie for the 7 seats going to the top 7 vote getters in the general election.

By far the strongest early showing on the streets is our incumbent mayor Bernard Carvalho: not just signs but he has people waving his signs by the highway. Last election he won easily and I have heard folks here opine that he doesn't have any serious competition this year. It's too early to tell as there are a few weeks left for candidate filings so the process has just begun.

So many people I have asked about local government shake their heads and complain. There certainly have been reasons to worry, but one easy improvement that is very doable is better voter turnout. In 2012 general election voter turnout was 62.9% (25,617 of 40,738 registered voters).

For politics, I realize this is a rather bland opinion-free posting, but I am just beginning to learn about all this so will wait until I actually have some insight before sharing my critical thoughts on candidates.

Official county elections information is available at kauai.gov/elections or see state elections where results will be posted.

May 1, 2014

Charter amendment amendment

More changes to the county charter are being considered. In another proposed amendment to the county charter, the Kauaʻi County Charter Review Commission held a hearing about upping the number of required signatures for amending the charter by the public from 5% to 20% of voters (based on number of votes in the last general election).

The stated motivation for changing the charter amendment signature requirement is that it should be higher than the requirement for placing a proposition (creating legislation) which is currently also 5%. Charter amendments certainly are changing a more fundamental layer of the legal system yet it seems that if anything the number of votes required for passage should be higher. Quite obviously, making it harder to put amendments on the ballot is hardly the same.

A summary of the percentage of vote signatures required by the major islands is instructive:

  • Kauaʻi county charter [link] 5% (72 pages)
  • Oahu  (City of Honolulu) charter [link] 10%
  • Maui county charter [PDF] 10% (62 pages)
  • Hawaii county charter [PDF] 20% (61 pages)
True, Kauaʻi does have the lowest bar for signatures to place proposed amendments on the ballot, yet do we want to jump to match the highest requirement? Since we are talking about effort to place amendments on the ballot a key consideration is if there are frivolous amendment proposals that the lower requirement is allowing that did not belong on the ballot in the first place or not. 

To support this I would like to see more of a justification, specifically where is the evidence that the 5% requirement is too easy? Have we had a problem with frivolous amendments get on the ballot? (Obviously some amendments will fail to pass, that doesn't mean they should never have been on the ballot.) On the other hand if we have had lots of amendments that only garnered 5% of the vote or something like that, I can see that as justification to raise the bar. In the 2012 election [results], nothing like that seemed to happen, so what's the motive? 

The real problem the county has been having with charter amendments is that they don't stand up in court: "For the second time in six years, a Hawaii court has invalidated a voter-initiated amendment to the charter". Due to a 2012 amendment the county attorney reviews amendments including "alteration or change in the form or language or any restatement of the text of the proposed amendments" (though the exact process is unclear).

My take on all this is that people are very rightfully frustrated with government. Many people here feel that this place is special, yet there is so much state and federal control on top of everything it often makes it difficult. 

This possible amendment seems unrelated, at least directly, to the effort to place an amendment to the county charter about GMO regulation. Even if both garner support they would appear together on the ballot later this year. 

The Fifth County

There is one more county in the state of Hawaii located in a remote part of Molokaʻi. Kalawao county (map), with a population under 100, is a special case with no elected officials. Maui county government supports Kalawao county as well as administer the rest of the island. Kalawao may be the least populous county in the United States (source). For obvious reasons their charter provisions isn't going to be comparable to the other counties, and actually I was unable to even find the document or even a web site for the county online.

April 20, 2014

The coming GMO battle: Kauai Charter Amendment Article XXXIII

As the ongoing legal wrangling over Kauai's Ordinance 960 continues, the next wave of political action is rolling out as a county charter amendment (full text) from Kauai Rising who has begun collecting signatures to put the charter amendment on the November ballot.
ARTICLE XXXIII - BILL OF RIGHTS 
TO PROTECT FROM HAZARDS OF GMO AGRICULTURE, TOXINS AND TESTING, ESTABLISH AN ADMINISTRATOR OF ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH, AND PROVIDE FOR ENFORCEMENT
GMO issues are complex and I won't attempt a position here. Without attempting a legal analysis either here are some first observations.

The amendment establishes a County Administrator of Environmental Health and a "panel of experts" that would report findings to the county council to approve any GMO activities on the island, with a provision allowing the council's decision to be overturned subject to petition by the public. Additionally there would be a monitoring effort, a containment requirement to prevent impact on neighboring property. All costs and overhead would be funded through what would have to be very expensive application fees and there would be significant civil as well as criminal penalties for violations.

The amendment begins with a detailed enumeration of rights: safe food, clean environment, protect communities, saving seed. The assertion of rights seems intended to address the legal challenge of local government typically being trumped by state and federal as I have written about previously.

The full amendment is 18 pages long - Kauai Rising provides a very brief summary. On the face of it the amendment appears to be a much stronger version of Ordinance 960 (which only required annual reporting of GMO activities and was largely about pesticide use and buffer zones) that squarely tackles GMO operations. Under the amendment, GMO operations would be required to demonstrate "beyond a reasonable doubt," that none of the rights are harmed.

The length of the charter amendment I find quite curious: this is about 25% the size of the entire county charter (72 pages). County departments like police, fire, water, and so forth each take up about two pages in the county charter. Is it really wise to embody so much detail in the charter itself rather than in ordinances and rules as the county generally operates? There does not seem to be a way to bundle a charter amendment with legislation accompanying it which is why I imagine the authors have piled all the details in, the alternative being a separate law-making effort that would become yet another battle.

Kauai Rising seems to be the authors of the amendment as I can find it nowhere else on the web. Who actually wrote the amendment and with what legal help is unclear. There is not much press on this yet. Kauai Eclectic is dismissive of the effort.

Throughout the battle over "The bill" (Bill 2491 which became Ordinance 960) there were vague claims that its passage would result in loss of jobs that I thought exaggerated. The amendment, on the other hand, seems a clear threat to the currently operating chemical companies and its passage (surely to be challenged in the courts) would very much be an existential threat to operations here. The stakes are much higher indeed if this manages to get on the ballot. Charter amendments require signatures of 5% of registered voters to get on the ballot.